Loading...

Rumble in the Publishing Jungle: Who Pays for Open Knowledge?

By  Abdul Syahid Nov 16, 2026 28 0

Muhammad Ali’s fights gave boxing some of its most unforgettable names. These include “The Fight of the Century,” “Rumble in the Jungle,” “The Phantom Punch,” and “What’s My Name?” Some were promotional fight titles. Others became popular nicknames. Heavyweight contests of its own, though its punches usually arrive as article processing charge (APC) invoices, peer-review invitations, and editorial deadlines. Everyone in this ring is fighting for knowledge. Not everyone pays the same price or takes home the same purse.

Open access (OA) has won an important round. Research once available mainly through subscriptions is increasingly accessible worldwide. Yet the theme of this year’s Open Access Week, “The Cost of Knowledge,” raises an uncomfortable question. When research becomes free to read, who pays to produce, evaluate, and publish it?

Joined into one sentence with “and their costs and rewards differ. OA has changed who pays without eliminating the bill.

The Fight of the Century: The Labor Behind “Free”

Platforms such as Open Journal Systems have made it easier for institutions and scholarly associations to run journals. Software, however, cannot evaluate research, resolve conflicting reviews, or safeguard publication ethics. Those tasks need academic expertise.

Reviewers scrutinize research methods and interpretations. Editors coordinate peer review, make editorial decisions, and address ethical concerns. Much of this labor is unpaid. A global study estimated that researchers spent more than 100 million hours reviewing manuscripts in 2020, a figure that excludes editorial work.

Voluntary academic service helps sustain scholarly communities, particularly in noncommercial journals. The economic relationship becomes more complicated when unpaid expertise supports revenue-generating publishing operations. Serving science and donating labor to a commercial enterprise.

“What’s My Name?”: When Recognition Becomes Revenue

Emerging journals invest in editorial governance, consistent publication, metadata quality, and international visibility. In countries such as Indonesia, inclusion in Scopus or Web of Science is often an institutional aspiration, shaped partly by national research evaluation priorities.

Such recognition reflects the collective efforts of authors, reviewers, editors, and institutions. It may attract more manuscript submissions. It can also create opportunities to generate revenue through APCs. Still, indexing does not automatically lead to publication fees or higher charges. Research suggests that the relationship between journal impact and APCs varies across disciplines.

The question is not whether journals should benefit from greater recognition. Rather, it concerns how the resulting economic value should be distributed among those who helped establish their reputation.

Super Fight II: Pay to Read or Pay to Publish?

An author may publish in a subscription journal without paying a publication fee. Publishing openly elsewhere may require a substantial APC. For an Indonesian researcher, a fee charged in US dollars, British pounds, or euros may amount to tens of millions of rupiah.

Subscription publishing generally places costs on libraries and readers. In contrast, APC-funded OA shifts them toward authors, institutions, and funders. Research on APC spending points to billions of dollars flowing through this system. Neither model makes scholarly publishing free. The cost simply changes corners.

The same APC can have very different financial consequences across research systems. A well-funded researcher may find a fee affordable. Someone without research funding may find it prohibitive. Research documentsthese inequalities in the ability to participate in fee-based OA. Publication charges may be internationally standardized. Their affordability remains profoundly local.

Waivers and discounts can help researchers with limited funding. Nonetheless, a larger question remains: Should the opportunity to publish openly depend so heavily on access to financial resources?

Thrilla in Manila: A Victory but a Relative One

OA has expanded access to scholarly research. Participation in publishing remains unequal. Readers may access articles freely while authors face publication fees. Meanwhile, reviewers and editors contribute expertise. Institutions finance research and infrastructure. Publishers operate under different business models.

Indonesia illustrates this tension. Research on its OA publishing landscape highlights a strong tradition of locally managed, nonprofit journals. It also identifies research evaluation pressures that may encourage publication in international outlets.

OA has widened access to reading more successfully than it has widened participation in producing and disseminating research. Recognizing this imbalance does not undermine OA. Instead, it highlights the need for more equitable and sustainable funding arrangements.

Battle of New Orleans: Making Knowledge a Public Good

Diamond OA offers a promising alternative. Authors can publish without paying fees and readers can access research freely. Eliminating these charges, however, does not eliminate publishing costs. The OA Diamond Journals Study emphasizes the importance of sustainable funding, effective governance, technical infrastructure, and editorial capacity.

Public universities and research institutions could treat scholarly publishing as shared academic infrastructure. They need not rely primarily on individual publication fees. Institutional budgets, library partnerships, scholarly associations, and funding consortia could support such arrangements. The Action Plan for Diamond OA also advocates sustainable, community-driven publishing models.

Transitioning to Diamond OA requires more than eliminating APCs. Publishing platforms, digital identifiers, preservation, production, administration, and professional services all require financial support. Institutions should also recognize editorial and reviewing contributions. Possible approaches include workload allocation, promotion criteria, professional development, and other appropriate forms of recognition.

Diamond OA is not publishing without costs. It is a model in which costs are shared rather than charged directly to authors and readers.

The Phantom Punch: Recognizing Labor Without Replacing Service

Commercial publishers provide valuable services. These include technology, production, preservation, and dissemination. Subscriptions, APCs, and institutional agreements can legitimately finance these activities. The concern is not commercial publishing itself. It is whether the academic labor supporting it receives appropriate recognition.

Peer review and editorial judgment are essential to journal credibility. Despite this, reviewers and many editors often work without direct compensation. Research examining the economic value of peer review underscores the substantial contribution of this scholarly labor.

Should these contributions automatically remain unpaid when publishers generate revenue? Compensating reviewers for every manuscript may not always be appropriate. Poorly designed incentives could encourage speed over quality. Alternatives include editorial honoraria, professional benefits, institutional workload recognition, and transparent compensation arrangements based on responsibilities.

The underlying principle is straightforward. Commercial publishers should acknowledge the economic value of the scholarly labor supporting their credibility and revenue. Appeals to academic service should complement transparency about how publishing benefits are distributed, not replace it.

The Last Hurrah: Who Takes Home the Purse?

The goal is not to declare OA victorious over subscription publishing. Nor is it to assume that nonprofit journals are always more equitable than commercial ones. The central issue is whether publishing costs, benefits, and responsibilities are distributed fairly.

Publicly funded institutions should strengthen sustainable Diamond OA wherever feasible. Commercial publishers should be more transparent about publication charges and about how they recognize academic contributions. Funders can invest in shared publishing infrastructure. Universities, in turn, can acknowledge editorial service as meaningful academic work.

Muhammad Ali famously said, “Service to others is the rent you pay for your room here on Earth.” Scholarly publishing depends on this spirit of service. At the same time, generosity should not obscure the economic value of academic labor. This is especially important when that labor contributes to commercial revenue.

The next victory for open knowledge will not come from one publishing model knocking out another. It will come from establishing fairer rules for everyone in the ring.

The final bell should not ring until three questions are answered: Who pays, who does the work, and who takes home the purse?

Keywords

Open access Article processing charges Diamond open access Scholarly publishing Peer review labor Publishing equity Open Access Week Indonesia Cost of knowledge Unpaid peer review Editorial labor Open access funding models Journal indexing Nonprofit journals Publishing infrastructure

Abdul Syahid
Abdul Syahid

Abdul Syahid has been teaching English since 1995 and earned his doctorate in English Language Teaching from the State University of Malang in 2015. Since 2020, he has served as a faculty member at Universitas Islam Negeri Palangka Raya, Indonesia. His research focuses on language testing and assessment. He actively collaborates with scholars from Indonesia, Malaysia, Iran, and the United States, including Professor Donald Freeman, on a nationwide teacher training initiative based on a global framework. He has reviewed over 120 manuscripts and serves on editorial boards such as SAGE Open while valuing time with his family.

View All Posts by Abdul Syahid

Disclaimer

The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of their affiliated institutions, the Asian Council of Science Editors (ACSE), or the Editor’s Café editorial team.

Recent Articles

Indexed but Hard to Find: Why Some Regional Journals Remain Invisible
Indexed but Hard to Find: Why Some Regional Journals Remain Invisible

As fellow academics, lecturers, and researchers in Indonesia, we fully understand the concerns surrounding this issue. We oft...

Read more ⟶

Tools Are Not the Bottleneck: Why Adoption Barriers Can Slow Innovation in Scholarly Publishing
Tools Are Not the Bottleneck: Why Adoption Barriers Can Slow Innovation in Scholarly Publishing

Scholarly publishing has never had so many digital tools. Manuscript management systems, online peer review platforms, resear...

Read more ⟶

Beyond the Metrics: The Human Future of Scholarly Publishing
Beyond the Metrics: The Human Future of Scholarly Publishing

I want to start with a confession. When I published my first research paper in 2023, I did not sleep the night befo...

Read more ⟶